The recent decision to remove Democratic Representative Ilhan Omar from the House Foreign Affairs Committee has been a source of controversy and debate. Proponents argue that it is important for members of Congress to be held to a high standard and that Rep. Omar’s comments on Israel and the pro-Israel lobby have the potential to harm U.S.-Israel relations. On the other hand, opponents argue that removing Rep. Omar is a violation of her First Amendment rights and an attempt to silence her critical views on U.S. foreign policy. Ultimately, the impact of this decision will depend on how it is perceived and implemented.